Frameworks

CommunicationAlso called And-But-Therefore, the narrative template

ABT (And, But, Therefore)

A three-beat shape for a pitch or update: set the scene, name the problem, say what follows.

In one look

  1. 1Set the scene with And.
  2. 2Turn it with But.
  3. 3Pay it off with Therefore.

Randy Olson left a tenured job in marine biology for film school, then spent years working out why expert explanations fall flat. In "Houston, We Have a Narrative" (2015) he says they're all "and": one fact after another with no turn. He took the fix from South Park's Trey Parker and Matt Stone, who join every story beat with "but" or "therefore."

The problem it solves

And, and, and.

The update is accurate and nobody remembers it. Every fact feels worth including, so they all go in, joined by "and." The hard part is finding the one "but" in your own material: the fact that makes the others matter.

Try it yourself

No sign-up, a few minutes. Five cards about the Post-it Note. Three make the story, two don't, and you build it.

The same update, with a turn

A newsletter team reporting to the people who fund it.

  • All "and"We've grown the list to 40,000, and open rates are steady...becomes We've grown the list to 40,000 and open rates are steady.
  • All "and"...and we've added two people to the team...becomes But almost none of those readers ever buy anything.
  • All "and"...and we're planning a refresh for Q3.becomes Therefore we're rebuilding the newsletter to turn readers into customers.

Good times to run it

  • A board or investor update that has to hold attention
  • The opening of a pitch or proposal
  • Campaign messaging built around one problem
  • The answer to "so how's the project going?"

When to skip it

  • Reference material. A spec or a price list should be complete, and a story gets in the way.
  • When there's no real "but." Inventing a conflict reads as spin.
  • Delicate news, where "therefore" sounds like a demand before anyone's ready.

Teams we've run sessions with:

  • Publicis Groupe
  • SoundCloud
  • WeTransfer
  • The New York Times
  • Columbia Business School
  • EY
  • Havas
  • NYC
  • MCI Group