Frameworks

StrategyAlso called Answer-first problem solving

Hypothesis-Driven Thinking

Start with your best guess at the answer, then spend the time you have trying to prove it wrong.

In one look

  1. 1Best guess first.
  2. 2Test what would kill it.
  3. 3Revise and go again.

It's borrowed from science: state the claim, design the test, go where the evidence points. Strategy consulting added the deadline. A scientist can wait for certainty and a client project can't, so firms took to naming a provisional answer on day one and spending the weeks testing it.

The problem it solves

Six weeks of research, and a finding everyone already knew.

Four analysts, forty charts, and a readout that says usage is down among younger members. Without a guess to test, every piece of analysis looks worth doing. With one, the risk is the opposite: you start collecting evidence that agrees with you.

Try it yourself

No sign-up, a few minutes. You run a campaign's sign-up page, and the team is sure the video will win. You pick the test.

The same six weeks, with a guess

A loyalty program in decline, and a team asked to find out why.

  • Researching the topicWe're researching the decline.becomes Day one: "Members earn points but can't spend them."
  • Researching the topicForty exhibits on who uses it.becomes Two weeks on redemption rates, abandoned redemptions and five member interviews.
  • Researching the topicUsage is down among younger members.becomes Half right. Redemption is hard only past a points threshold, and that's what they fix.

Good times to run it

  • The first week of a diagnostic or strategy project
  • Evaluating a deal. Say why it works, then attack that.
  • Choosing what to analyze when the deadline can't move
  • A steering meeting that needs one claim to test

When to skip it

  • When you like your guess too much. You'll stop testing and start collecting support.
  • Open exploration, like user research or a new market. An early guess narrows what you notice.
  • Clients who need to see an open mind. Some hear "hypothesis" as "you'd decided before you arrived."

Teams we've run sessions with:

  • Publicis Groupe
  • SoundCloud
  • WeTransfer
  • The New York Times
  • Columbia Business School
  • EY
  • Havas
  • NYC
  • MCI Group